This is second post based upon the Guilford Courthouse Battleground leadership walk.
Level 5 Leaders
As the leadership group followed Dr. Bowman, our facilitator, to the large and beautiful monument of General Nathanael Greene the discussion turned to what is a Level 5 leader and why are there not more of them. Level 5 leadership theory comes from a study conducted by Jim Collins and written about in his exceptional book, Good to Great. Mr. Collins, in a nut shell, explains that a Level 5 leader is one who builds an enduring greatness and legacy through personal humility and professional will power. These two attributes may seem on the surface contradictory, but not necessarily so as will be explained as we move forward. Let us now look at what makes Level 5 leaders, why there aren’t more of them at the top of organizations and how we might change that.
In my 54 years of life I, like many of you, have had the opportunity to observe many different people in numerous walks of life. Plainly speaking, my experiences lead me to believe there are two kinds of people in this world; there are givers and there are takers. Without sounding too pessimistic, most people, as a general rule, tend to fall into or closer to the taker side or category than the giver side. Looking after number one at others’ expense is a way of life with far too many people including leaders. This attitude and way of life is nothing more than a selfish egotistical existence, where one consistently puts himself and his wants and needs first. It is only when organizational or others’ needs align with theirs are their efforts considered mutually beneficial.
Perhaps you think I am being overly dramatic or pessimistic? Maybe so, but think back across the years of your professional and life experiences and count the number of top level leaders you have worked with or are familiar with who always put the organization and its members first and themselves last. I will bet you did not use all of your fingers on just one hand, did you? Now count the others, the takers. If you need to, take your shoes off and count on your toes. The plain but sad truth is that the takers outnumber the givers considerably.
The takers are the ones who always looks for their personal advantage or gain in every situation. Their thought process is always me first and everyone else second. Every decision or action is always preceded with questions such as, “Is this going to help me get promoted”, or “will this help me get a pay raise”, “will this help me get a corner office”, or “how is this going to benefit me?” These types of leaders are what General Norman Schwarzkopf calls careerist. Every decision a careerist makes is premised upon what is best for the leader; not the team or the organization. You get the idea; the mentality is that it is always about me, me, me. It is my world and you are just traveling through it. The shame is that far too many of this type of leader get into high positions within organizations.
Level 5 leaders are just the opposite. Level 5 leaders are the rare but unique individuals who are humbled and caring. They are the leaders who have a strong belief in the organizational mission and higher purposes. They also believe in a high moral standard to care for the needs of other people and to fight for higher causes. They see others in the organization as team members and not adversaries to step on or over on the way to the top. They do not see employees as just a pair of hands, as did Henry Ford. Rather they see other people as individual human beings with families, needs, hopes, dreams and concerns of their own.
“The problem of power is how to achieve its responsible use rather than its irresponsible and indulgent use - of how to get men of power to live for the public rather than off the public.”
General Nathanael Greene |
I submit to you that Level 5 leaders want and use power for the public and organizational interest and not for personal gain. Nathanael Greene was a Level 5 leader. Did you know that when the government was unable to supply his army with needed provisions, he personally signed the notes and requisitions to buy them? He became personally responsible for the payments. Does this sound like a leader who only cares for his own well being? I would venture to say that he cared first and foremost for his soldiers and the cause he was fighting for. After the war he had to sell much of his property to pay these war time obligations. This is the stuff of Level 5 leadership!
Why then do so few Level 5 leaders rise to the top of organizations? My experience again tells me that there are quite a lot of Level 5 leaders in the middle and lower echelons of organizations. Yet too few rise to the highest ranks of the organization. You know the ones I am talking about; the caring and giving first line supervisors and the district commanders who work their tails off to meet the organizational goals while simultaneous taking care of their people. They are the ones that you have seen go to mat fighting for your best interest even when you may not have deserved it, or when it may not have been in their best career interest to do so. They are the ones who assume the risk of being seen as “disloyal to the boss” as they fight for and stick up for their people.
Shamefully, very few of these Level 5 leader types ever make it to the top rungs of the organization. Again, why do you think this so? Surely they earn it and deserve it more than the leaders of the “taking mentality.” It is my belief that they are too busy doing their jobs and doing what is best for the organization and others to take the time to promote their individual interest. They are consumed with the organizational mission and work extremely hard to fulfill it. They believe in the cause; they believe in what they do, and they work to accomplish it! They are not concerned about the spot light but quietly work behind the scenes like Trojans to get the job done. They just do not take the time to advance themselves in the minds and eyes of the powers to be. They have their priorities in the proper order. Generally these are the people who have a clear and deep understanding of what is important in life and what is not. Rank, power and position is important to them, but not the most important thing. It is not as important as fulfilling their duty, doing their job excellently, taking care of their people or meeting the goals and mission of the organization. But I submit to you that more Level 5 leaders should do a more effective job in getting themselves and others into positions of power and influence. It should be done the Level 5 way!
Every organization has Level 5 leaders within its ranks. Are you one? If not then I challenge you to develop yourself and others into Level 5 leaders and then find ways to get yourself and other Level 5 leaders into positions of greater power and influence within the organization. Always remember there is nothing wrong with putting yourself in your best light with those who have control over your career. Just learn to sell yourself in a Level 5 way; a way that does not diminish your humility, your values, and your character, and does not diminish others in the process. You do not have to back stab and cut throats to get your deserved recognition. We should see the acquiring of power and position as a way to help the organization and your people and not as a way to just help yourself. Seeing power and position in this light should lead Level 5 leaders to put more emphasis on the necessity of gaining personal power and position. Remember power is not a bad thing if used for greater purposes other than yourself.
I also think that Level 5 leaders have a rare gift for being lifted to the top from below, rather than pulled up from the top. They have a unique ability to achieve both power and position through helping others fulfill their talents and abilities. They do this while maintaining their own dignity and self-worth. Perhaps Level 5 leaders who make it to the top of their organizations are just better at balancing these different dimensions. It is not an easy task, if it were there would be more Level 5 leaders at the top. My final challenge is for you to go as far as your talent will carry you in your organization just do it the Level 5 servant way! That is how you serve the organization and its people. That is the way to leave a Level 5 legacy of service, humility and character.
Have a great and safe week! LeaderUp!
Esse Quam Videri!
Carpe Diem
Arete'